Brussels – Almost seven years have passed since the UK formally withdrew from the European Union, and more than ten years since the referendum that paved the way for Brexit. Seven prime ministers later, it seems that the time has finally come for 10 Downing Street to acknowledge Brexit’s structural failures, with Andy Burnham offering a new approach that contrasts with those of his predecessors.
“He has decided the best thing to do is to be honest with the British people. He has stopped trying to pretend that it was a good idea, but badly executed,” explains Ian Bond, Deputy Director of the Centre for European Reform (CER), speaking with The New Union Post. While his Labour predecessor, Keir Starmer, was more inclined to make Brexit work, the former Mayor of Manchester and new leader of the Labour Party is arguing that Brexit cannot work because it could never have worked in the first place.
Ahead of the second EU–UK Summit on 20 November, this approach could pave the way for “a more honest conversation,” both within the UK and with its counterparts in Brussels. “Whether it is going to work or not, we do not know, but what he is trying to start at the moment is a debate on what the options are,” Bond points out.
The post-Brexit options
It was on 29 September that Burnham, in his first speech at the Labour Party Conference as leader, announced a review of the “different options” for the UK’s long-term relationship with its European partners. “There are different options, and I will see if we can find consensus around one, which will give us clarity about our position and the future of the continent that we live in,” he said. But what are these options?
Burnham himself clarified that the review would consider four possibilities: maintaining the status quo; joining a customs union; joining the EU’s Single Market through sectoral agreements, along the lines of Switzerland’s relationship with the EU; or going “all the way” by applying for EU membership and rejoining the European Union. In recent days, he has been a little more explicit about his hopes that the UK will rejoin the EU sooner” than previously suggested – namely within his lifetime.

While the more bespoke options of a customs union or partial membership of the Single Market “are probably much more difficult to negotiate because there is no template” available – and they would also entail complex negotiations “on what should be covered and what should not, under what terms, and all sorts of complications” – Bond identifies the status quo and full EU membership as “the two easiest options.”
As for the possibility of the UK rejoining the European Union, “there is a clear template” for EU accession with six clusters and 33 chapters, “and once you have ticked all of the boxes, then it is up to the existing member states to decide whether they want you.” In other words, this process would be easier only in terms of the negotiations, particularly given the extent to which London remains aligned with the EU acquis despite years of Brexit. “Whether full membership is a simple process politically is another question,” Bond warns.
A promising summit
An early test of Burnham’s new approach to Brexit will come at the second EU–UK Summit in Brussels on 20 November. The summit will mark the first formal meeting between the new UK Prime Minister and the leaders of the EU institutions – European Council President António Costa and European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen.
CER’s Deputy Director expects a “quite low-key and technical” summit, focused on “useful technical and not super high-profile issues,” while also indicating the way forward on areas such as the electricity market, defence, economic security, steel trade and digital cooperation.
The package of deals is expected to include agreements on sanitary and phytosanitary regulations – that will make trade in agricultural goods “much easier” – on linking the EU and UK emissions trading systems, on a youth mobility scheme – with “some sort of compromise” on the fees EU students will have to pay to attend UK universities – and a memorandum of understanding on health security. As Bond highlights, “these are definitely steps in the right direction that create a better atmosphere” for the debate Burnham wants to launch in the UK “on the nature of our future relationship with the EU.”
All this could help address both the thorny question of which clauses should be included in the EU–UK “reset” and the chaotic moment when Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland are eyeing independence from the UK and a return to the EU. Moreover, Burnham’s new approach to Brexit could represent not only a bold electoral move to consolidate Labour’s lead over Nigel Farage’s Reform UK, but also an ambitious offer from a staunch supporter of devolution to Brussels, that would need firm guarantees that London would not simply walk away again.
The state of EU–UK relations
The UK applied for EU membership in 1961 and again in 1967, and joined the Union in 1973. After more than 40 years of membership, it became the first country to voluntarily withdraw from the EU following the 2016 referendum, when 51.9% of voters opted to leave. Brexit officially entered into force on 31 January 2020, followed by a year of negotiations to define the terms of the withdrawal agreement.
Since 1 May 2021, post-Brexit relations have been governed by the EU–UK Trade and Cooperation Agreement, which includes preferential arrangements in areas such as trade in goods and services, intellectual property, public procurement, transport, thematic cooperation and participation in EU programmes. The agreement also establishes a new framework for law enforcement and judicial cooperation in criminal and civil matters.
However, the UK government’s attempts to unilaterally reject the terms of the agreed Northern Ireland Protocol exacerbated post-Brexit tensions until the successful negotiation of the Windsor Framework in 2023. Since then, relations have significantly improved.
During the first EU–UK summit, held in 2025, the two sides agreed on a strategic partnership identifying areas for future work to strengthen relations – including a youth experience scheme, the UK’s association with the Erasmus+ programme, UK participation in the EU electricity market, a common area for sanitary and phytosanitary products, and linking the two emissions trading systems.
Discover more from The New Union Post
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.































